Each year the Department of Mathematics selects an outstanding senior. The outstanding seniors beginning in 1985 are listed below.
- 1985: Melissa Cockrell
- 1986 Gordon clark
- 1987 Steven Cudd
- 1988 Craig Cox
- 1989 Cassandra Chadd
- 1990 John Garnett
- 1991 Joy Cregan
- 1992 Michael Oehrtman
- 1993 Michael Oberle
- 1994 Dustin Carr
- 1995 Gretchen Crouch
- 1996 Michael Holcomb
- 1997 Shannon Ingle
- 1998 Jeffrey Whitworth
- 2000 Benjamin Wescoatt
- 2001 Kyle Wichert
- 2002 Mario White and Kristin Wilkinson
- 2003 Frantisek Krepelka
- 2004 Nathan Pennington
- 2005 David Page
- 2006 Liangkin Li
- 2007 Michael Kelly
- 2008 Michelle Leonard